blue
oklahoma
...anything but sad...

(HOME)
"This land is your land, this land is my land"-Oklahoma's own Woody Guthrie




Affirmative Action Programs Create Opportunities

by: DocHoc

Tue Jun 19, 2012 at 13:58:58 PM CDT


Image of diverse hands

A state question that will appear on the ballot in November will effectively end affirmative action in Oklahoma government, consequently furthering institutionalized discrimination in the state.

SQ 759, which would amend the constitution, is a bad, needless measure that ignores the recent history of people being denied opportunity because of race or gender. It presumes discrimination no longer exists and that people now have equal opportunity, which is simply not true.

Affirmative action programs help prevent discrimination through awareness and offer people inclusion. They have never been intended to deny other people opportunities.

DocHoc :: Affirmative Action Programs Create Opportunities
The amendment, sponsored by state Sen. Rob Johnson, a Kingfisher Republican, would cover employment, education and contracting in government. According to language listed on the Oklahoma Secretary of State's office, "In these areas, the measure does not allow affirmative action programs. Affirmative action programs give preferred treatment based on race, color or gender. They also give preferred treatment based on ethnicity or national origin. Discrimination on these bases is also not permitted."

The measure allows some exceptions, including federal mandates or when gender is a "bonafide" qualification.

It's somewhat unclear, perhaps deliberately so, what the main reasoning is behind the measure, but another one of its sponsors, state Sen. Ralph Shortey, an Oklahoma City Republican, said, "One of the big reasons we need it is Oklahoma is perceived nationwide, and it is not warranted, as a racially biased state. We don't need that."

Of course, the amendment would send the exact opposite message, as I wrote here, about Oklahoma, which does have a long history of discrimination and intolerance that still echoes today.

One of the supporters of the measure is Ward Connerly, who heads the American Civil Rights Institute ACRI, an organization that works to end affirmative action programs nationwide. Connerly, who is of African American and Indian descent, once said affirmative action causes resentment, according to CNN.

Is the issue, then, for ACRI what has been described as reverse discrimination? According to CNN, Connerly said Caucasian students might feel resentful if they didn't get accepted into particular colleges if minority students with less stellar academic records did get accepted.

The issue of banning the use of affirmative action in college admissions has been a contentious issue in other states, including California and Texas, but I don't know of any similar issue here.

As far as I know, Johnson, Shortey or anyone else in favor of the amendment has never cited an example of this or any example of what they might describe as reverse discrimination in Oklahoma. Thus, the measure is entirely based on a particular ideology and worldview, not evidence, at least here in Oklahoma.

The ACLU of Oklahoma is opposing the measure. One point it makes is that the measure could affect programs for a wide group of people. According to the state's ACLU's web site:

SQ 759 threatens . . . a range of targeted programs that most voters may not associate with "discrimination" and "preferences" at all: science and technology programs for girls, higher education funding for minority health professionals, review systems designed to monitor and address discrimination, domestic violence programs, breast cancer screenings, and much more.

The attack on affirmative action is really an attack on the basic principles of the Civil Rights Movement in the 1960s. It's also a denial of systemic discrimination that manifests itself in myriad, sometimes subtle ways. Affirmative action programs create opportunities while acknowledging reality, and they are still vital in our culture.

Tags: (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email

Menu

Make a New Account

Username:

Password:



Forget your username or password?


Search




Advanced Search


About
This is a community blog operated since 2006 by people dedicated to promoting and restoring progressive values in Oklahoma. A courageous band of patriots, we fight right-wing tyranny in one of the reddest of red states. Do you want to help by posting here? Do you want traffic back to your blog or site? We welcome posts written by liberals and centrist to conservative Democrats and Independents. Contact kurt.hochenauer@gmail.com. Be sure to check us out on Facebook, and feel free to leave comments there about individual posts.
Subscribe in a reader


Some Oklahoma Blogs, Sites
Okie Funk
Oklahoma Gazette
Oklahoma Observer
Oklahoma Policy Institute Blog
Red Dirt Report
The Lost Ogle


National Sites
  • Agonist
  • Angry Bear
  • AmericaBlog
  • Annatopia
  • Arch Pundit
  • Atrios
  • Booman Tribune
  • BOP News
  • Body & Soul
  • Blogometer
  • Big Brass Blog
  • Booman Tribune
  • Burnt Orange Report
  • Carpetbagger Report
  • Common Blog
  • From Left Field
  • Crooks and Liars
  • Colorado Luis
  • Democratic Underground
  • DC's Political Report
  • Daily Kos
  • Drew Miller
  • DC Media Girl
  • Desert Rat Democrat
  • Down With Tyranny
  • Donkey Rising
  • Digby
  • Davenetics
  • Ed Cone
  • Ezra Klein
  • Gregs Opinion
  • FireDogLake
  • Hotline On Call
  • Horseass
  • Ise Fire
  • Juan Cole
  • Josh Marshall
  • Left in the West
  • Liberal Oasis
  • Left Coaster
  • Mathew Gross
  • My Left Wing
  • Mystery Pollster
  • Oliver Willis
  • O'Toole File
  • Off The Kuff
  • Ornicus
  • Pacific Views
  • Political Wire
  • Political Dogfight
  • Politics 1
  • Senate Guru
  • Swing State Project
  • skippy
  • Seeing the Forest
  • Talking Dog
  • Talk Left
  • The Moderate Voice
  • The Next Left
  • TBogg
  • The Fix
  • Unfutz

  • Powered by: SoapBlox